Teeters Main Dessert Menu

Welcome to the staple desserts of our bakery

Teeters Fan Favorite Desserts

These are Teeters Bakery fan favorite desserts for you to indulge in to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings.

Tati's Blueberry Lemon Scones

Blueberry Lemon Scones have always been a comfort treat for me in my hardest times. These scones can cheer up anyone especially on a rainy day. -Tati (@tatidom_)

8 Scones

$31.00

16 Scones

$59.00

24 Scones

$84.00

Julio's Alfajor Cookies

One of many Peruvian dessert staples. -Julio (@julio_huamantupa)

20 Cookies

$32.00

40 Cookies

$55.00

Keahi's Tiramisu Cookies

A delight To set hearts alight And wings in flight This tiramisu will make your day (Or night!) -Keahi (@x_kwb_x)

12 Cookies

$24.00

24 Cookies

$41.00

Teeters Treat Wave of '26

This summer, a Treat Wave crashes onto the Teeters menu. (July 1st-September 21st)

Ballantine Blue Sugar Cookies

A classic delicious sugar cookie topped with blue sprinkles inspired by the Newark Museum's Ballantine House Blue colorway.

24 Ballantine Blue Cookies

$33.00

48 Ballantine Blue Cookies

$60.00

Tree nuts

Strawberry Moon Scones

Enjoy the cool, calm summer nights looking at the moon while you indulge in these lite n' fluffy Scones, making nights magical.

12 Moon Scones

$35.00

24 Moon Scones

$63.00

Sun-Kissed Banana Pudding Muffins

Embrace the heat of the summer sun with these Sun-Kissed Banana Pudding Muffins, making the heat more tolerable and fun.

12 Sun-Kissed Cupcakes

$44.00

24 Sun-Kissed Cupcakes

$80.00

Cookies and Brownies

Who doesn't love a good cookie or brownie to share with their favorite people. Even if it's just for yourself, we won't tell everyone deserves to be a little selfish sometimes.

Emily's Cosmic Brownie Remix

8 Brownies

$32.00

16 Brownies

$58.00

24 Brownies

$81.00

Jalani's Oatmeal Cookies

Classic Oatmeal cookie with a sweet vanilla glaze.

28 Cookies

$43.00

56 Cookies

$77.00

Jaz's Red Velvet Cookies

Pick you choice between our Red Velvet Cheesecake Cookies or our Red Velvet Chocolate Chip Cookies. Either one would be an amazing edition for any event

14 Cheesecake Cookies

$34.00

20 Chocolate Chip

$32.00

28 Cheesecake Cookies

$58.00

40 Chocolate Chip

$58.00

Julio's Alfajor Cookies

One of many Peruvian dessert staples. -Julio (@julio_huamantupa)

20 Cookies

$32.00

40 Cookies

$55.00

Keahi's Tiramisu Cookies

A delight To set hearts alight And wings in flight This tiramisu will make your day (Or night!) -Keahi (@x_kwb_x)

12 Cookies

$24.00

24 Cookies

$41.00

Khy's Brownie Cookies

A piece of heaven to make hell melt away. -Khy

16 Cookies

$31.00

32 Cookies

$53.00

Kenny's Chocolate Brownies

In a world where things seem to be moving at 5x speeds, it can easily get overwhelming and stressful. Sometimes just a simple sweet treat can help you melt away life stresses. Giving you that much needed breath of fresh air and a sign that things will eventually get better overtime. -Kenny (@kenrick.wilson1)

16 Brownies

$37.00

32 Brownies

$65.00

Nas's Chocolate Chip Cookies

The perfect balance of chewy, gooey and chocolatey!!!! -Nas

20 Cookies

$31.00

40 Cookies

$53.00

Cookies type

Soft Baked

Crispy Baked

Cakes and Cheesecakes

Celebrating a special occasion? What could be a more perfect dessert to share with friends, families, or a loved one, than a great tasting cake or cheesecake

Blueberry Lemon Layer Cake (NEW)

Enjoy a twist on our most popular dessert on the Teeters Dessert menu. We take our Tati's Blueberry Lemon Scones flavors and turn it into a gorgeous 3 Layer 6 inch with a Lemon-Vanilla Cream Cheese Frosting.

$45.00

Crème Brulee Cheesecake

This lovely desserts brings two popular desserts on a collision course and creates a spectacular tasting piece of art.

1 Pie (9x9)

$48.00

6 Cheesecake Cupcakes

$45.00

Ladybug Cheesecake Bites

Delicious, Savory, Sweet Treat! Fell in love with every bite. -Taneisha (@innhercityblues)

6 Cheesecake Cupcakes

$45.00

12 Cheesecake Cupcakes

$81.00

Walnut Graham Cracker Crust

Walnut Crust

$3.00

Mar Mar's Funfetti Birthday Cake Cupcakes

Funfetti birthday cupcakes with a dash of rainbow sprinkles will always be a welcomed party in mouth! Yum! Wait, who's birthday is it for today. Order yours in a 14 standard size or 7 jumbo size cupcakes. -Mar Mar (@mar.malade22)

14 Cupcakes

$54.00

7 Jumbo Cupcakes

$54.00

28 Cupcakes

$97.00

14 Jumbo Cupcakes

$97.00

Mar Mar's Funfetti Birthday Cake Cupcakes

Tiara's Caramel Cheesecake

This cheesecake is perfectly sweet with a cloud like texture. Which makes it soft and airy with a light rich flavor that melts in your mouth. -Tiara (@_tiarafitch_)

1 Pie (9x9)

$50.00

6 Cheesecake Cupcakes

$47.00

Trevor's Key Lime Pie Cheesecake

A dessert like this can symbolize life. From the tartness of the key limes meaning hardships and pain. To the cheesecake mixture reminding you that you're not alone and that people are always in your corner. The 2 sides clash together to make life more manageable, with the cheesecake mixture minimalizing the tartness of the key limes. Just like how having people who truly care and love you, can help minimalize the blow of life struggles. This combo creates not only something special in a dessert but as well as in real life.

1 Pie (9x9)

$44.00

6 Cheesecake Cupcakes

$40.00

Pastries

Welcome to in my opinion the most unique part of the menu. 5 desserts, 5 different spectrums to indulge in. What more can I say, than enjoy.

Cinnamon Rolls (Classic, Red Velvet)

12 Original Rolls

$32.00

12 Red Velvet Rolls

$35.00

24 Original Rolls

$58.00

24 Red Velvet Rolls

$63.00

Freya's Eclairs

8 Eclairs

$19.50

16 Eclairs

$35.00

Flavors of Fillings

Plain

Coffee

$3.50

Caramel

$2.80

Jermaine's Cream Puffs

The older sibling to the popular French dessert Eclairs. These bite size pastries will make your day with it's light flakey shell and rich vanilla or chocolate custard

20 Cream Puffs

$33.00

40 Cream Puffs

$60.00

Custard Filling

Vanilla Bean

Chocolate Cinnamon

$2.50

Lucy's Lemon Bars

These Lemon bars are the perfect dessert to share with your most treasured loved ones and make moments even more memorable.

15 Lemon Bars

$37.00

30 Lemon Bars

$65.00

Tati's Blueberry Lemon Scones

Blueberry Lemon Scones have always been a comfort treat for me in my hardest times. These scones can cheer up anyone especially on a rainy day. -Tati (@tatidom_)

8 Scones

$31.00

16 Scones

$59.00

24 Scones

$84.00